Skip to content
193 Shares

The Rob Roy cocktail was said to be invented at the Waldorf Astoria hotel in New York City, named after a Scottish outlaw in the 1700s, who later became a folk hero. The drink named for him is the drier cousin to the Manhattan, using blended Scotch whisky in place of the rye or bourbon. Unlike single-malt scotch, blended scotch is made from barley as well as other grains and is usually only lightly peated, so it has less of the smoky flavors that are a feature of many single-malt scotch whiskies.

Although wildly popular in its day, the Rob Roy has sadly been foreshadowed by the Manhattan, a cocktail I like a lot. But sometimes Iโ€™m looking for something drier, with a subtle hint of smokiness, but not enough to make it an all-out fume-fest. And thatโ€™s when the Rob Roy rides in.

The classic Rob Roy uses aromatic bitters, an all-encompassing term that refers to bitters that are a melody of spices, none not always more prominent than the others. (Although clove and allspice sometimes canโ€™t help but elbow their way forward.) Another feature of aromatic bitters is its rosy color, which brightens up any cocktail a dash or two of it is added to, as it does here.

Rob Roy cocktail

Some like to add an orange twist in addition to, or instead of, the cherry. I have been known to tip in a scant 1/4 teaspoon of the cherry juice to balance the cocktail a little better, as I found the cherry sweetness rounds out the vermouth and bitters in the drink. (I did once order a Manhattan in a dive bar and the bartender added a generous pour of the juice from the jar of maraschino cherries, which was way too much. But a tiny dash does hight the other flavors.)
Servings 1 cocktail
  • 2 ounces blended Scotch whisky
  • 1 ounce sweet vermouth
  • 2 dashes aromatic bitters
  • 1/4 teaspoon candied cherry juice, optional, (from the jar)
  • candied or maraschino cherry, for garnish
  • Add the whisky, vermouth, bitters, and cherry juice (if using) to a mixing glass.
  • Fill the glass three-quarters full with ice cubes and stir briskly until well-chilled, about 15 seconds. Strain into a chilled cocktail coupe. Garnish with cherry.
193 Shares

20 comments

    • Briana

    A favorite! The timing on the Rob Roy (with an orange twist) is perfect, itโ€™s chilly here in VA today and I need some fortification. I will try to wait until sometime after 8am thoughโ€ฆ

      • Jerry Griffith

      What other cocktails do you like or want to try on the brisk and getting colder mornings? I will try your suggestion with the cherry juice for a smooth taste and see how it is!

    • Daniel

    Thank you for sending some love to Rob! And thank you for your food and drink, your writing and recipes: Iโ€™m a long time fanboy. Because I gravitate toward less sweet cocktails, Iโ€™ve become a devotee of the โ€œperfectโ€ Rob Roy: 50/50 sweet and dry vermouth.

    • Rob Taylor

    Iโ€™ve never thought to order a cocktail at a dive bar, just beer but am thinking my dive bars might be more โ€œdiveyโ€ than yours.
    I think I often overlook just how very good a writer you are as tend to focus on the food story you are sharing..but I guess that is characteristic of an excellent prose person & you are that.
    โ€œAnd thatโ€™s when the Rob Roy rides inโ€ is a great line.

    • Emelle

    Step 2 means ice, yes?

      • King Ed Ra

      My default cocktail when Iโ€™m out drinking. If Iโ€™m home or at a swanky enough bar, Iโ€™ll swap out the blended scotch with an Islay single malt and add a splash of absinthe. I like that idea of adding the cherry juice from the bottle.

    • PF

    I donโ€™t ever have Maraschino cherries on hand, but I always have tart dried cherries for baking, and theyโ€™re actually quite sweet. Iโ€™ll try plumping a few cherries in the whiskey first.

      • Janet Miller

      I love this idea!

      • Niki

      We soak dried tart cherries from Trader Joeโ€™s in cognacโ€” delicious garnish, 3-4 on a toothpick, and the soaking cognac is a wonderful addition to many Manhattanesque cocktails we enjoy

    • Thomas Dino Malle

    Nice. Forgot about good olโ€™ Rob Roy. I am a rye Manhattan fan. But When I run dry now I can dip into partners scotch. Thanks.

    • Dianne Obeso

    David Thank you for years of writing and enjoyment. I used to go to SF for classes at Tante Marie and feel I rubbed elbows with some lovely people you have known up there. Oh for better times.. and hope for more of the same at some point.

    • met0813

    My father and uncle drink a Perfect Rob Roy which substitutes dry vermouth for the bitters. They never waste time stirring with a spoon either; their finger does the trick perfectly!

    • john v burke

    What they said about enjoying the blog. Also a question: are you familiar with Punt e Mes? Itโ€™s a sweet vermouth, or anyway an Italian vermouthโ€“I think itโ€™s ideal in Negronis and Iโ€™ve used it in cooking to deglaze a pan after cooking fennel. Worth a try.

      • Nanda

      I love Punt e Mes. It works perfectly in a Scofflaw too.

    • Jan

    Iโ€™m in absolute agreement with comments about your writing, David. Itโ€™s always a joy, as are your recipes.

    • Susan S.

    Sounds wonderful! My husband is a huge fan of the Manhattan. I always go for a bit dryer. I look forward to
    making your Rob Roy tomorrow for our cocktail hour.
    I just ordered your book, โ€œDrinking Frenchโ€, and am so looking forward to experimenting the many delicious sounding drinks you have mentioned.
    Thank you again for your wonderful writing .
    Susan S.

    • Gail

    Drank far too many of these in college when the drinking age was lowered to 18 my freshman year. Trying to be cool, I guess.
    Not drinking now due to mouth ulcers, but this will be my drink of choice when/if they go away.

    • David
    David Lebovitz

    Thanks for all your kind words and glad youโ€™re enjoying the blog! (And some of the drinks, tooโ€ฆ)

    : )

    • Lena

    Am I the only one that thinks of Chandler ordering a Rob Roy?

    • Bill

    I suggest a dash of Luxardo maraschino liqueur rather than just cherry juice: a bit more complex, a delicious part of my standard Manhattan or Rob Roy.

A

Get David's newsletter sent right to your Inbox!

15987

Sign up for my newsletter and get my FREE guidebook to the best bakeries and pastry shops in Paris...